Boundary setting scale
Contents
About
I'm fascinated by and passionate about Consent. I've spent years learning about it, trying to teach it in a modest way (in dance workshops and in new relationship), and even wrote a book called Consent to Kiss. But the more I learn, the more I realise how much nuance there is. Consent isn't just about saying "yes" or "no". It's about knowing what you want, recognising when something doesn't feel right, and having the confidence to communicate that. It's about Setting Excellent Boundaries.
One thing I've increasingly noticed is how many people struggle to set healthy boundaries. I've particularly noticed this with women, although men struggle too, sometimes in less obvious ways. Some people know exactly what they want but are afraid to say it. Others communicate their boundaries beautifully, only to let them slide when someone pushes back.
That's what inspired this Boundary Setting Scale - a playful but serious look at how well we recognise, communicate and maintain our boundaries.
The Three Cs of Good Boundaries
I like to think of good boundaries as having Three Cs:
- Clear — No ambiguity. Say what you mean rather than hoping someone will read your mind.
- Comprehensive — Cover what's off-limits. Think about the situations where your boundaries might be tested, and what you are and aren't comfortable with.
- Consequences — What will you do if someone crosses your boundary? Leave the situation? End the conversation? Tell someone? A boundary without follow-through can become little more than a polite request.
For example, instead of saying "Please don't be disrespectful", you might say:
"I'm happy to discuss this, but I'm not comfortable being shouted at. If the shouting continues, I'm going to leave the conversation."
That's clear, specific and gives you an action you can take.
Boundaries aren't walls — they're gates defining what you welcome and what you won't accept. They're not about controlling other people. They're about choosing what you will participate in.
Why Setting Boundaries Can Be So Hard
Setting boundaries sounds simple in theory. In practice, it can be surprisingly difficult, especially when we care about someone, fear rejection or don't want to create conflict.
I've noticed that people who are particularly kind, empathetic or eager to please can sometimes struggle the most. They may be wonderful at respecting other people's boundaries but less confident expressing their own.
This can also have a cultural dimension. In some Asian cultures, for example, there can be a strong emphasis on harmony, politeness, respecting authority and avoiding confrontation. These can be beautiful values, but depending on someone's upbringing and experiences, they may also make direct boundary-setting feel uncomfortable.
I've met people who find it incredibly difficult to say something as simple as:
- "Hey, can we stop?"
- "I'm actually uncomfortable right now."
- "I'd rather not."
- "I need a little space."
- "No, thank you."
Of course, this isn't unique to Asian cultures, nor does it describe everyone from those backgrounds. People-pleasing exists everywhere, and confidence with boundaries varies enormously between individuals.
Sometimes the difficulty goes deeper than politeness. When someone feels unsafe, overwhelmed or afraid of upsetting another person, they may enter a fawn response — trying to please or appease someone to avoid conflict or danger.
This is related to the familiar fight, flight and freeze responses. Fawning can be an automatic survival response rather than a conscious choice.
See also my Comfort to Growth Scale for more about the difference between healthy discomfort, growth and situations where we feel overwhelmed or unsafe.
Boundaries and Self-Respect
One of the most interesting parts of this scale, to me, is the middle.
Someone at level 5 might be perfectly capable of saying:
"No, I'm not comfortable with that."
But then someone pushes back, persuades them, makes them feel guilty or simply ignores the boundary. And they give in.
Once might be understandable. But when this becomes a pattern, something important can happen: we start losing trust in our own ability to stand up for ourselves.
We might feel disappointed, frustrated or resentful — not just towards the person who crossed our boundary, but towards ourselves. I think this is an important distinction. Knowing your boundaries, communicating your boundaries and maintaining your boundaries are three different skills. And all three take practice.
Boundaries and Consent
This is particularly important in dating, intimacy, massage, dance and other situations involving physical touch.
A person might appear happy, smile, laugh or even say "yes", while internally feeling uncomfortable.
Sometimes they're trying to be polite. Sometimes they're afraid of disappointing someone. Sometimes they freeze or fawn.
Silence, compliance or a lack of resistance should never automatically be interpreted as enthusiastic consent.
This is why I believe consent is a shared responsibility.
We should all learn to express our boundaries more clearly, but we should also become better at noticing hesitation, checking in and making it genuinely easy for someone to say "no".
If someone seems uncertain, slow down. Ask. Give them space to change their mind.
And remember that consent can be withdrawn at any time.
Respecting Other People's Boundaries
There's another important dimension that doesn't quite fit on the graphic.
Being excellent at setting your own boundaries doesn't automatically mean you're good at respecting other people's.
Someone could be extremely assertive about what they want, yet repeatedly pressure others to compromise their own comfort.
That's not healthy boundary-setting.
Healthy boundaries go both ways.
They involve being clear about your needs while respecting another person's right to have different needs, preferences and limits.
And sometimes the healthiest response to incompatible boundaries isn't compromise. It's recognising that two people want different things and respectfully going their separate ways.
Final Thoughts
I don't believe anyone is permanently a 2, a 5 or a 10.
You might be excellent at setting boundaries at work but struggle with them in romantic relationships. You might confidently say "no" to strangers but find it almost impossible with family members.
And you might be great at boundaries one day and struggle the next.
The goal isn't perfection. It's awareness, practice and self-respect.
A healthy boundary doesn't have to be aggressive, cold or confrontational.
Sometimes the strongest boundary is simply a calm, compassionate:
"No, thank you."
"That doesn't work for me."
"I'm not comfortable with that."
"I'm going to leave now."
Kind. Clear. Firm.
And perhaps most importantly, remember that you don't need someone else's permission to have a boundary.
See Also
- Setting Excellent Boundaries' - Follow on from this article.
- Consent to Kiss — My book exploring consent, intimacy and communication.
- Comfort to Growth Scale — Understanding comfort, growth and overwhelm.
- Open Communication Scale — How openly do you communicate?
- Feedback Reception Scale — How well do you respond when someone tells you something uncomfortable?
